If George Strait’s Voice Fell Silent, Which Song Would You Play First?

Introduction

What if one day the world had no George Strait? It’s a question best considered with a favorite record playing. Put on “Amarillo by Morning” and listen to how easily his voice settles into the company of the fiddle. The man in the song has spent years on the rodeo circuit, and he takes stock of what the road has cost him with the plainness of someone who has had plenty of time to think it over. Strait gives the man room to keep his dignity. That choice tells us a great deal about why his records have stayed close to so many listeners.

One of Strait’s gifts is his understanding of how people speak when a feeling runs deep. Listen to “I Cross My Heart.” There’s a warmth in the way he holds the longer notes, but the promise at the center of the song comes across with the ease of a conversation. You can imagine it being sung at a wedding and then heard again, decades later, by the same couple on an ordinary drive home. The first time, they might hear all the possibilities ahead of them. Years later, they might think of the small, unremarkable things they did to keep that promise.

In “The Chair,” Strait brings the same conversational touch to a sly little story. A man opens with a remark about a chair and uses it as an excuse to keep talking. By the time the last line comes around, the listener has to reconsider the first one. Strait’s delivery makes the whole exchange feel spontaneous. You can almost hear the smile he’s saving for the end. It’s a fine example of how much an accomplished country singer can do with timing alone. A phrase can carry a joke simply because he knows how long to let it hang in the air.

Then there’s “The Cowboy Rides Away,” a song that gives us a familiar Western image and the less familiar feeling of having to live with a goodbye. The melody rises, and Strait lets you hear what it costs the singer to say his piece. There’s a little distance between the steadiness of the voice and the hurt it conveys. Anyone who has tried to get through a goodbye without losing their composure may recognize that distance. It’s one reason the song can feel more personal as the years go by.

If the thought of a world without George Strait makes you reach for one of his records, your choice might say as much about your life as it does about his music. Perhaps “Check Yes or No” takes you back to a schoolroom and the nerve it took to pass a note. Perhaps “Amarillo by Morning” reminds you of somebody who made a living on the road and seldom complained about it. A beloved singer can give ordinary memories a sound you recognize in the first few bars. The song you’d play first is probably the one that already brings someone, or somewhere, back to you.

Video