The Voice That Had to Follow a Legend: How Jimmy Fortune Helped Write the Statler Brothers’ Next Great Chapter

Introduction

Listen to The Statler Brothers Songs | Spotify

Joining a beloved musical group is one thing. Stepping into a place held by a voice that listeners have welcomed into their homes for years is something else entirely. When Jimmy Fortune joined The Statler Brothers in 1982, he entered a musical family whose harmonies already carried the weight of memory. For longtime listeners, those voices belonged to Sunday afternoons, familiar radio stations, and records played until every phrase felt like an old friend. A change in that sound could never be merely a change in personnel.

The circumstances made the transition especially poignant. Lew DeWitt, a founding member whose tenor had helped define the group, was struggling with Crohn’s disease, which ultimately forced him to leave. Fortune initially came aboard as a temporary replacement, with DeWitt himself having recommended him after hearing him sing at a ski resort. Fortune performed his first show with the group on January 28, 1982, in Savannah, Georgia. That recommendation gives the story a touching foundation: the departing singer helped open the door for the man who would carry the tenor part forward.

For an audience attached to an established harmony, a new singer brings an unavoidable question: will the music still feel familiar? The challenge reaches beyond hitting the correct notes. In a vocal group, every entrance, held vowel, and carefully balanced phrase contributes to a shared identity. Fortune’s clear, ringing tenor brought its own character to that balance. Listening to his work with Harold Reid, Don Reid, and Phil Balsley, one hears how a distinctive individual voice can strengthen an ensemble through careful attention to the others.

Then came “Elizabeth.” Written by Fortune, the song became a No. 1 country hit for the Statlers in 1984. He also wrote two further chart-toppers, “My Only Love” and “Too Much on My Heart.” These achievements gave his place in the group a significance that extended well beyond the demands of replacing a familiar singer. His songwriting helped supply the material through which listeners would come to know this new chapter of the Statlers’ sound. countrymusichalloffame.org

There is a particular grace in “Elizabeth” that makes it an ideal introduction to Fortune’s contribution. The melody gives his tenor room to rise, while the surrounding harmonies provide warmth and reassurance. His delivery carries longing with a directness that suits the song. For listeners who appreciate a melody they can remember and a feeling they can recognize, the performance offers lasting pleasure. Its emotional strength comes from the relationship between the soaring lead and the steady voices supporting it.

🎶 Two hours. Nothing but Statler Brothers requests. And nothing was off  limits. We got talking with Brian Kennedy about one of our favorite nights  on the cruise — taking requests with

That musical relationship helps explain why this story remains so moving. Listeners could continue to treasure Lew DeWitt’s legacy while discovering what Jimmy Fortune brought to the group. Affection for one chapter made room for another. Anyone who has lived through changes in a family, a workplace, or a cherished community may recognize the patience such a transition requires.

Fortune’s arrival reminds us that continuity takes people willing to contribute something of themselves. His voice and songs became part of the Statlers’ enduring musical identity. Return to “Elizabeth” with that history in mind, and the recording gains another layer of meaning: a newcomer finding his place, four voices learning their balance, and a beloved group discovering how much music still lay ahead.

 

Video