Dolly Parton’s Best Comebacks Reveal What Makes Her Songs So Good

Introduction

Ask Dolly Parton what she wants written on her tombstone, and she’ll give you a pizza order. The interviewer has barely finished inviting her to reflect on her legacy before she’s thinking about pepperoni and olives. It’s one of the smallest moments in this collection of interviews, and it may be the best introduction to her way with words. A single word carries two meanings. Dolly lets everyone get comfortable with the first before she slips in the second. By the time you realize where she’s taken you, you’re already laughing.

That ear for a turn of phrase is part of what makes Dolly Parton’s songwriting so rewarding. Think of the opening of “Jolene.” The singer addresses the other woman by name, and the repeated name keeps pulling us back to the woman she’s pleading with. The guitar pattern moves steadily underneath, giving the song a sense of urgency even when Dolly’s voice stays remarkably composed. In the tombstone joke, one word changes the direction of the conversation. In “Jolene,” one word holds the whole conversation in place. Both show how much she can do with a phrase simple enough to remember on the first hearing.

The interviews also capture the pleasure Dolly takes in deciding how to present herself. When Barbara Walters suggests she could give up the wigs and striking clothes, Dolly hears a chance to explain why she chose them in the first place. Then she makes being fashionable sound like the easiest thing in the world. Her delivery is as important as the line. She answers in an easy, conversational voice, as though the two of them were discussing what to wear to dinner. The calmness gives the comeback its bite, and she can make her point without souring the conversation.

There’s a similar ease in the way she talks about Whitney Houston and “I Will Always Love You.” When the conversation invites a comparison between the two versions, Dolly makes a joke about how well Houston’s recording worked out for her as the songwriter. It’s a funny answer because it acknowledges the business side of music so plainly. It also gives both performances room to be appreciated. Dolly’s recording has the intimacy of someone choosing her words carefully at a difficult goodbye. Houston lets the same farewell swell until it fills the room. Listening to them side by side brings out just how much feeling Dolly put into a melody that can sustain both readings.

Then there’s Miley Cyrus’s cassette story, which closes the distance between the star on the talk-show couch and the musician trying to get a recording to someone. As Miley tells it, the audio passed from cassette to flip phone and eventually made its way to an iPhone. Anyone who has ever transferred a favorite recording to a new machine can appreciate the comedy of those extra steps. There’s affection in the telling, too. You can hear how much Miley enjoys explaining the roundabout route that brought Dolly’s voice to her.

The next time you listen to Dolly Parton, pay attention to what happens just before a line lands. On television, she gives the host a moment to settle into the question. In a song, she might let the guitar carry the tension or lean into a word you’ve already heard her sing. Those choices make her performances feel like conversations you want to stay in. And sometimes, when everyone is expecting a solemn answer, the line she’s been saving is an order for pizza.

Video