Introduction

For anyone revisiting Alan Jackson at the 57th Annual CMA Awards – Show, the moment worth listening for is when Jackson and Zac Brown Band arrive at “Margaritaville.” By then, the tribute to Jimmy Buffett has already made room for sorrow, and the familiar melody gives the audience a chance to join in. Jackson has a gift for making a song feel as easy as a conversation, even in an arena. At Nashville’s Bridgestone Arena on November 8, 2023, that gift suited a performance that had to hold two feelings at once. There was the sadness of losing Buffett and the pleasure of hearing a song that had made people smile for decades.
Kenny Chesney and Mac McAnally, a longtime member of Buffett’s Coral Reefer Band, opened the tribute with an acoustic performance of “A Pirate Looks at Forty.” It was a telling choice. The lyric follows a man who suspects he was born too late for the life he might have been good at. Buffett had a knack for slipping that kind of regret into a melody you could hum on the way home. Giving the song an unhurried opening let its words carry the weight. It also gave listeners time to think about the songwriter whose sense of humor could sometimes draw attention away from how closely he observed people.
When Alan Jackson and Zac Brown Band followed with “Pirates and Parrots” and “Margaritaville,” the music opened up. Jackson’s voice works especially well in a group performance because his phrasing is so recognizable at an ordinary singing volume. He lets words settle at the ends of lines, and his Georgia drawl gives even a familiar phrase its own rhythm. There is a dry smile in “Margaritaville” that suits him, too. The song’s narrator spends much of his time taking stock of his troubles, and the joke grows gentler as he comes around to the possibility that some of them are his own doing. A singer who sounds comfortable with that admission can make the whole room feel in on it.
The order of those songs is part of what makes the tribute worth returning to. Had it opened with the biggest chorus, it would have been an easy invitation to sing along. Starting with the more reflective “A Pirate Looks at Forty” meant that, by the time the chorus of “Margaritaville” arrived, listeners had already spent a few minutes with the more wistful side of Buffett’s writing. The audience could hear both sides of him in one sitting. That is a generous way to remember a songwriter whose most famous tune has been played so often that it’s easy to forget how much personality there is in the verses.
Perhaps you first heard Buffett on a car radio, or maybe the song belongs to a particular summer when somebody always had music playing in the kitchen. Those are the memories a familiar chorus can call up in a few bars. As the arena joined the singing at the 57th Annual CMA Awards, Jackson and the other musicians gave those private memories a place in a public farewell. You can hear why the chorus belonged at the end. By then, the people singing it had something of their own to bring to it.
#countrymusic #music #cowboys